I'm now 100% certain which squash plant is which. The growing one is spaghetti squash, and we should have a decent yield as long as they get a chance to ripen or close to it before it gets cold. I noticed a bit of powdery mildew when I was watering a while ago, but it got completely out of control when the mosquitoes were bad and Chemguy didn't tell me. I'll be trying milk or baking soda, next year I know to treat that stuff early, I thought I would have to buy something and never got around to going which is why I waited a while.
The butternut squash was a non-vining variety, I wonder if that's why they were slower growing. Both still had the same space requirements listed, so I didn't expect there to be a big difference in their growth, but the spaghetti clearly are growing outwards while these are a nice little bushy plant now. I have some tiny fruit on them and will be thrilled if we manage to get anything edible from them. I've seen small butternut squash in one grocery store, is there a trick to get them to ripen sooner? Does the cooler temperatures induce that?