Seeler
Well-Known Member
Has anyone read "The Secret Chord" by Geraldine Brooks. My book club has done several of her books and I always enjoyed them, finding them well researched and well written. We didn't do "The Secret Chord" but I read it on my own and wasn't disappointed. It is Biblical fiction focusing on the life of David as seen by the prophet Nathan. Much of it covers events found in the Hebrew scriptures (the books of Samuel, Kings, Chronicles and some of the Psalms), but it also expands it to explore his possible relationship with his family of origin, King Saul and his family, Jonathan, his wives and children. This was particularly interesting to me as a few years ago I drafted out a book about King David's Wives, particularly Michel. I found Geraldine Brooks interprets the brief references to them found in the Bible quite differently than I do.
I liked the book.
Then a friend noticed it in my house. She had read it for her church's book club. She hated it. In her view it was just a lot of made-up stuff to disgrace a Biblical hero. "No where in the Bible does it say that David's father and brothers picked on him." "No where in the Bible does it say ... "
I got the impression that she considered it blaspheme and people who read it and enjoy it are at risk of denying everything they were taught in Sunday School or always believed about 'the shepherd boy who become king'.
Has anyone read it? What did you think?
Is there any place for Biblical fiction (ie books like this, or "The Red Tent")?
I don't think I'll let her read my book about David's wives. I also took liberties with Scripture.
I liked the book.
Then a friend noticed it in my house. She had read it for her church's book club. She hated it. In her view it was just a lot of made-up stuff to disgrace a Biblical hero. "No where in the Bible does it say that David's father and brothers picked on him." "No where in the Bible does it say ... "
I got the impression that she considered it blaspheme and people who read it and enjoy it are at risk of denying everything they were taught in Sunday School or always believed about 'the shepherd boy who become king'.
Has anyone read it? What did you think?
Is there any place for Biblical fiction (ie books like this, or "The Red Tent")?
I don't think I'll let her read my book about David's wives. I also took liberties with Scripture.