Good war movies

Welcome to Wondercafe2!

A community where we discuss, share, and have some fun together. Join today and become a part of it!

The_Omnissiah

The God of All Machines
I've been watching a lot of quality war movies lately and figured I'd throw a thread up so people with suggestions or looking for good movies can come check it out!

I picked war movies specifically to have a clear theme and not cause an endless list of every movie imaginable :P

Cross of Iron and All Quiet On the Western Front are both really good anti-war war movies (and the two films I watched on Sunday that inspired this thread). The former being about a Prussian officer who comes to the eastern front to win the Iron Cross, and his interactions with a gritty sergeant and his band of German 'Kelly's Heroes' type squadmates who has already won the Iron Cross - and lost all illusions as to what war is. The latter is a seminal WW1 movie filmed in the 1930s. Black & white (and originally a silent film), it documents a class of friends who all enlist at the behest of their patriotic professor and slowly have their ideological bases dismantled by the brutality of war and loss of friends.

Rambo: First Blood is another good movie. Well filmed and despite the pro-Viet Nam stance of Stallone, gives a vivid (albeit fantastical) view of PTSD and the societal rejection of Viet Nam veterans.

Intimate Enemies is a film about the French in Algeria and how a soldier with noble ideas slowly realizes the genocidal effect of colonialism that is being enacted through himself and the other soldiers. He is dismayed to find out that those in command have deemed it necessary and won't listen to his appeals to humanity.

Enemy At The Gates is a film about the siege of Stalingrad during WW2, from the point of view of both the Russian defenders and their champion sniper, and the Germans and a veteran sniper they bring in to eliminate him. With excellent cinematography showing the devastation of Stalingrad, the movie also shows the war through the eyes of a snipers, which not too many other films do.

The Red Baron is a German film produced in English documenting the rise to fame of Baron von Richtofen - the Red Baron. The film examines the airmen's views of combat: with many noble holdovers and notions of honour in war being present. This is contrasted by the brutality of warfare on the ground. These two opposing views come closer and closer together and clash within the characters in the film. With most of the characters being real historical people, the film does a good job of examining that time period and the people that inhabited it.

Flame & Citron is a Danish movie about two Danish resistance fighters who do what is necessary to combat the occupation of their country. Assassinating Danish collaborators and Nazis, destroying infrastructure, and disrupting Nazi rule, these two show the vicious nature of guerilla resistance during the second world war.

Patton. This seminal film about the famous (or infamous) U.S. General Patton follows his career throughout WW2. His belligerent and gung-ho attitude earned him as many allies as enemies. His strange (to say the least) views on destiny and other things put him apart from his time. With such quotables as "Rommel you magnificent bastard, I read your book!", it is a must see for any fans of war - especially WW2 - films.

Das Boot is a German language film about a U-boat crew during the second world war and the ignoble job they are tasked with. A gritty and realistic portrayal of life as a kriegsmarine with no ideological fanaticism, this film does a good job of showing one of the branches of the German military with the highest attrition rate.

The Longest Day is a film about the D-Day invasion and the time preceding and immediately following it. Showing that tense period through the eyes of Generals, civilians, and grunts, the film helps give watchers a sense of the magnitude of the undertaking that was the Normandy invasion.

We Were Soldiers is a film about the first combat use of US air cavalry in Viet Nam and the logistical, and emotional struggles involved. Showing both the combat side of things and the civilian repercussion (with mention of the racism of the times) the film does a good job of capturing those early days in Viet Nam when the U.S. assumed invincibility.

Emperor documents the end of WW2 as the U.S. manoeuvres carefully in its administration of Japan to prevent all out civilian rebellion. You can cut the tension with a knife as General MacArthur eventually meets the Emperor personally.

My Way is an incredible, nigh on unbelievable film about two young runners, Korean and Japanese, whose lives become intertwined during Japanese occupation of Korea. Their lives continue as the Korean is drafted into the Imperial Army under the eventual command of the Japanese. Their animosity slowly turns into friendship as their military misadventures take them from fighting the Russians, to fighting for the Russians against the Germans, to fighting for the Germans and being stationed in Normandy, only to then experience D-Day. Excellent cinematography and acting, and most incredibly, it is based on a true story!

Black Hawk Down presents an all-star cast representing U.S. military personnel during the Mogadishu crisis in Somalia. A brutal film, it gives a good representation of the isolation, stress, and vivid destruction involved in modern city fighting.

Into The White is a film about two air crews, one British, the other German, having been shot down over Norway. Stumbling upon each other at a mountain cabin, a tense truce is declared as power changes hands back and forth throughout their trials in the dead of winter. Eventually they come to see each other not as enemies, but as fellow humans, each with a background and story to tell, and you get to see many sides of humanity in that small Norwegian cabin.


Those are just a bunch of excellent films I've seen before that I could think of off the top of my head. Feel free to contribute by giving your own reviews and/or suggestions!

-Omni
 
I am glad to see First Blood on there. It is often condemned by association with the sequels, which abandoned the notion of a troubled vet struggling and made him into a jingoistic war hero fighting the "Evil Commies".
 
That's why I only mentioned the first one. After that I would consider them more 'cheesy action flicks' than 'war movies' despite the settings. ...also why I didn't include Red Dawn ;)

-Omni
 
Good list

I've got fav's for different reasons

If I want to feel like I'm in a war, all I have to do is play the beachhead scene from Saving Jason BournePrivate Ryan

If I want the longest relentless schmaltz-that-made-me-feel-horror-make-it-stop! movie, that would have to be Schindler's List

My favourite Good vs. Evil war movie was Platoon.

The most poetic & High Concept war movie was Thin Red Line. Multiple characters. Multiple storylines. Beautiful poetry. Beautiful scenes. Earth as wonder. The movie is a dialogue, delving into why is there violence and death amongst all this beauty & wonder? This movie thematically ties in well with another Terrence Malick work, the very spiritual The Tree of Life

My favourite american Civil War movie is still The Good, the Bad, the Ugly

The classics will always remain classics to me. A Bridge Too Far. The Great Escape. Life is Beautiful. The War of the Roses. I Was a Male War Bride.
 
Saving Private Ryan has such a crazy cast! It's like Black Hawk Down in that way.

I would take Platoon over Apocalypse Now any day. One is an excellent movie about the personalities involved in a brutal war and how the war affected the people/how the people affected each other. The other is a poor attempt at an artsy film that plays with consciousness and drags on way too long.

The Four Feathers
and Lawrence of Arabia are both excellent period pieces as well.

-Omni
 
Sort of peripheral to the war per se but has guys in military garb: The Wahnsee Conference. It's a dramatization of the meeting where the Nazi brass planned the extermination of the Jews. It's based on the actual minutes of the meeting and has this horrific contrast between the Nazi officers and bureaucrats being very ordinary human beings (chatting about families, flirting with secretaries, playing with dogs) and the subject matter of the meeting. On paper, should be boring as hell. As made, drop the "should be boring as" part. It is fascinating in the worst possible way. This could almost qualify as a horror movie.
 
I've watched documentaries about that meeting, and how the Nazis were overjoyed that if they presenting things in a bureaucratic way - statistics and percentages - the common folk could mentally justify/deal with the horrendous things they were party to.

-Omni
 
"The Great Escape". I haven't seen this in awhile, but I remember watching it a few times when I was younger. I think it was based on a true story. Enjoyed Steve McQueen in this one.

HBO's Band of Brothers
 
I'll put in a plug for a 'women's experience" war movie, Mrs. Miniver.

It was my grandmother`s favourite movie, and I like it because it reminds me of her.

And being a sucker for romance and sentimental drama, I`m also partial to From Here to Eternity.
(Love Frank Sinatra in that war flick. Not often that we see Frank Sinatra as all acting, all drama and no music.)
 
Loved Mrs. Miniver and "The Best Years of Our Lives" both numerous Oscar winners, but you don't see a lot of action in those movies.
 
That's another kind of war movie, isn't it? The "home front movie" I guess you could call it. The Dresser, starring Albert Finney and Tom Courtenay is another good one, though the war tends to be more in the background in it.
 
Enemy Mine two bitter enemies are forced to survive together

"Soldier", an Outer Limits Episode

"Paladin of the Lost Hour" episode of The Twilight Zone. This one makes me cry

Ender's Game which I had been eagerly awaiting. Totally gave me

Starship Troopers by Paul Verhoeven. Completely different from the source material, I enjoyed this because of the hilarious ads (just like in the original robocop) and Doogie Hauser as a telepathic SS Ossifer

Honorable mentions: Black Book also by Verhoeven, following a young jewish woman trying to survive in occupied Holland and the amazing things that her countryfolk will do to try to deal with the occupation. Over the top in some places (the scene with the unusual use for chocolate), but this movie really got past my defences and lasted with me for over a year.

Inglourious Basterds -- a marvelous, award-winning tour de force wish fulfillment epic. Full of everything that makes his movies fun films.

Not really war movies:

The Mission. Not really a war movie, but this movie moves me greatly. For the longest time after, whenever I heard the music I'd cry -- at the beauty and the horror behind the song -- here was a true story of a people who's whole way of life was being raped away by the church, and yet here they were, singing beautiful songs by the church...

Captain Phillips. A real horror movie for me that, when the finale happened, I felt what Captain Phillips was feeling. High tension tale of human beings reacting to impossible situations (like how the Somali fisherfolk have to survive -- death by starvation, death by warlord, or piracy...)
 
Last edited:
What's the name of that one from the 1930s, I remember so well. Three English brothers leave home and join the French Foreign Legion. They end up at a fort in the desert under a cruel and sadistic commander. Only one brother survives. I believe there was a remake a few years ago. Like many, the remake was not nearly as good as the black and white original.

Another excellent war movie - I think it was called "Lifeboat". Actually I think it was set just after WW2. A passenger ship hits a floating mine and sinks very quickly. In the aftermath there is only one overcrowded lifeboat - full of people and with a storm coming on. The dying captain tells the only other officer that he has to lighten the boat - and it becomes that man's job to decide who will live and who will die. Those who are badly injured are the first to be thrown overboard - including the parents of a young child. Next it is the elderly, and those who do not have the skills or strength to contribute to the survival of the group. Good movie.
 
Worth checking out is "The Beast." It was made in 1988, and it's the only movie I can think of that deals with the Soviet war in Afghanistan. Like most American movies of the era, it's a bit over the top in its portrayal of the Soviets, but it's interesting. It deals with a Soviet tank battalion lost in the Afghan desert and struggling to find its way out and under the command of a rather insane officer, played by George Dzundza. Almost 30 years later, it's interesting to be reminded that in 1988 the mujahadeen were friends with the Americans. Pretty violent, but maybe even more interesting today because of how the years since have unfolded.
 
Thought of the name of the French Foreign Legion movie I mentioned above - Beau Geste. Beautiful gesture.
 
Back
Top