Beyond Labels

Welcome to Wondercafe2!

A community where we discuss, share, and have some fun together. Join today and become a part of it!

Mystic

Well-Known Member
I make no apologies for my responses in the Trump thread, from which I'm now banned, but do want to indirectly respond (if indirectly) to Inana Whimsey's question about how I view labels like "progressive" and "conservative" in everyday life. My best example focuses on the "gay" vs. "straight" label.

When I was a UMC pastor of a 2-church charge in western New York, one church had 3 active gay members, the Worship Chair (Bob), a Communion steward (Mark), and a choir member. Most members probably didn't know these men were gay. Then Mark got the flu, which I soon learned was a euphemism for AIDs. When I visited him as he lay dying in the Emergency ward of complications from pneumonia, I'm still haunted by a smirking doctor who burst through the Emergency doors. laughing, "Well, I've seen that before!" At Mark's funeral. I rejected one anti-gay member's plea to mention Mark's sexual orientation and the cause of his death. Mark was well loved for his kindness. As a baker, he used to donate free pastries and cakes to the elderly shut-in women of our church. Ignoring the gay label unleashed incredible love.

(2) When our organist died, Bob recruited a gay (non-Christian) Jewish jazz musician (Jon) from Rochester to serve as our pianist and music director. He took the job only for some quick and easy cash, but soon was gloriously converted. Jon's musical role became permanent and he asked me to baptize him
. I didn't dare address the gay issue from the pulpit; so I decided to offer a gay-friendly Bible study for these 3 men and whoever was interested. To my dismay they invited other gay friends from Rochester and soon several gay and lesbian young adults started attending our church from Rochester. Miracles began to happen rivaling Gospel miracles.

Someone asked these gays and lesbians why they didn't attend one of the progressive "open and inclusive" churches in Rochester, given that our church was conservative and traditional in its attitude towards sexuality. The answer was unexpectedly profound: "Because those churches accept us only out of political correctness and we prefer the unique warmth of loving encounters here that look past personal beliefs to our individual personalities. The love here seems more authentic."

P.S. My censure means I'll renege on my promise to demonstrate why Northwind's view of Jesus' and Paul's spirituality is seriously flawed and will take another extended absence in favor of other websites where less rancorous discussion is more viable.
 
I make no apologies for my responses in the Trump thread, from which I'm now banned, but do want to indirectly respond (if indirectly) to Inana Whimsey's question about how I view labels like "progressive" and "conservative" in everyday life. My best example focuses on the "gay" vs. "straight" label.

When I was a UMC pastor of a 2-church charge in western New York, one church had 3 active gay members, the Worship Chair (Bob), a Communion steward (Mark), and a choir member. Most members probably didn't know these men were gay. Then Mark got the flu, which I soon learned was a euphemism for AIDs. When I visited him as he lay dying in the Emergency ward of complications from pneumonia, I'm still haunted by a smirking doctor who burst through the Emergency doors. laughing, "Well, I've seen that before!" At Mark's funeral. I rejected one anti-gay member's plea to mention Mark's sexual orientation and the cause of his death. Mark was well loved for his kindness. As a baker, he used to donate free pastries and cakes to the elderly shut-in women of our church. Ignoring the gay label unleashed incredible love.

(2) When our organist died, Bob recruited a gay (non-Christian) Jewish jazz musician (Jon) from Rochester to serve as our pianist and music director. He took the job only for some quick and easy cash, but soon was gloriously converted. Jon's musical role became permanent and he asked me to baptize him
. I didn't dare address the gay issue from the pulpit; so I decided to offer a gay-friendly Bible study for these 3 men and whoever was interested. To my dismay they invited other gay friends from Rochester and soon several gay and lesbian young adults started attending our church from Rochester. Miracles began to happen rivaling Gospel miracles.

Someone asked these gays and lesbians why they didn't attend one of the progressive "open and inclusive" churches in Rochester, given that our church was conservative and traditional in its attitude towards sexuality. The answer was unexpectedly profound: "Because those churches accept us only out of political correctness and we prefer the unique warmth of loving encounters here that look past personal beliefs to our individual personalities. The love here seems more authentic."

P.S. My censure means I'll renege on my promise to demonstrate why Northwind's view of Jesus' and Paul's spirituality is seriously flawed and will take another extended absence in favor of other websites where less rancorous discussion is more viable.
Thanks :3

Breaks are good

I heartily reccommend them

When you come back, the WC gulags will be up and ready lol
 
My censure means I'll renege on my promise to demonstrate why Northwind's view of Jesus' and Paul's spirituality is seriously flawed and will take another extended absence in favor of other websites where less rancorous discussion is more viable.

I don't recall you ever making such a promise, nor do I ever express my view on Jesus' and Paul's spirituality. Are you making things up?

I can live without such an explanation.
 
will take another extended absence in favor of other websites where less rancorous discussion is more viable.
Browse this sight they have over 70,000 members -----you will be more well received there ----all kinds of different Forms to view as well -----many Bible believing members there as well as non believers ----more tolerant of scripture and True Christian beliefs -----

 
There is Gai (happy) and those flat out straight lying there seriously ... without curves they can't get around a serial thing put down ... myth? It is described in some terms as unknown, mystery and understood poorly ... so pay attention to the bits and chits ... they're detailing's ... sent to us as a test ... and some of the firmer get really testy about being presented with what they don't know or precisely the great unknown that is extensive beyond some mortal abstract ... imagination in limited form? Profound in all vectors ... if frightening the tensor ... it appears ...

@Mystic ... have you ever read The Swerve ... a text on the character (nature) of things ... eliminating non-things or nein things as Muses that are not physical? I've recommended it to theologians that said they couldn't read it as it was a mystery to them understanding matter and immaterial character of energy expressed ... yet it may be character building in the great extent of God boxed up in a confined story ... in includes nothing!

I suspect you will not understand as you put alien data down ... subversive? These trends run to insurrection ... the urge to control the uncontrollable as much of it is intangible ... like the shadow of psyche that cannot be seen! The serious ignore that faction ... as a haunting ... concern about what we don't know could be critical ...

Actually how does the great bit we don't know conflict with the wee bit we do and deny ... so as to proclaim naivete, innocence and ignorance of what we should have learned when the chance flashed by ... now we are headed down the tubes due to the brain drain ... it appears collectively! Immortal sharing ... the great gap is open ...

Did you swallow it or did it swallow you ... the misty information? It is feint in the denying psyche ... allowing that demiurge of internal gnawing ... consuming fixation?

Scarcely accepted by the pious who are hard! Bones in the story ... over great time fossils that fool one as they are really stoned ... what happens when virtue is denied in favour of the lie ... something Dais ... some say Daze ... in determinate state!
 
Last edited:
Someone asked these gays and lesbians why they didn't attend one of the progressive "open and inclusive" churches in Rochester, given that our church was conservative and traditional in its attitude towards sexuality. The answer was unexpectedly profound: "Because those churches accept us only out of political correctness and we prefer the unique warmth of loving encounters here that look past personal beliefs to our individual personalities. The love here seems more authentic."
It sounds, though, like your church was not one of the really conservative ones, just traditional-leaning. They let you baptize them without them giving up their homosexual behaviour, as would happen in some of the really seriously anti-gay churches. They seem to have had a chance to prove themselves and be accepted. And good on that church for learning from the experience and maybe becoming a bit open.

One thing people at the liberal end of the spectrum tend to forget is that gay people are a very diverse bunch. Some of them actually want a fairly traditional theology, for instance, just one that accepts them for who they are. I know Metropolitan Community is (or used to be) fairly traditional in some of their theology. We had a lesbian couple at the UU fellowship end up going to them for that (and other) reasons. Jesus as Saviour of humankind has appeal for a marginalized group like LGBTQ+. They just see that their orientation/identity is not a barrier to that salvation. Something like Calvinism or universalism where God's Grace is given without condition can be very powerful when you've been rejected time and again for who you are.
 
The question is and remains for any church that says "we don't need to care if you are gay":
do you recognize significant anniversaries of couples in your church? if so, do you know when your couples that are gay celebrate their anniversary?
would a couple give a quick kiss to their husband or wife in front of other church members, if so, would the gay couple feel comfortable doing so?
Do couples sometimes hold hands when sitting in a pew or during a service? Do couples sometimes get overwhelmed emotionally by the beauty of a piece of music or in another setting? funeral? Would a gay couple feel comfortable doing so?

If the gay couple does not do something that straight couples do, then odds are, you aren't truly embracing them for who they are and welcoming them into your community.
 
The genuine friendliness of a congregation is not paired closely to its theology. What is a progressive church? Is there one definition for progressive churches? I believe a lot depends on the focus of a church. Some are focused on intellectual or theological issues. Some are focused on relationships. DRCC is open theologically. Relationships matter most there. The same applies to Knox Wesley United Church in Grenville, Quebec.
 
The genuine friendliness of a congregation is not paired closely to its theology. What is a progressive church? Is there one definition for progressive churches? I believe a lot depends on the focus of a church. Some are focused on intellectual or theological issues. Some are focused on relationships. DRCC is open theologically. Relationships matter most there. The same applies to Knox Wesley United Church in Grenville, Quebec.
Yeah, I have been in some very friendly evangelical congregations and some very unfriendly progressive and UU ones. How a congregation welcomes people is more a function of people that theology. How it treats them in the long haul, though, can very much be a function of theology and social outlook.
 
If the gay couple does not do something that straight couples do, then odds are, you aren't truly embracing them for who they are and welcoming them into your community.

This is an excellent point. I often look at certain people behaving and ask how that behaviour would be accepted if the person were female. Or brown. Etc.

I would also want to know if a gay couple could get married in that church that says they accept gay people
 
We had a fun wedding three Saturdays ago. A bunch of us marched in Pride, at 2, then the Rev and the couple driving the decorated car, in their matching rainbow suits, rushed off to the church for their 4 p.m. wedding.
 
This is an excellent point. I often look at certain people behaving and ask how that behaviour would be accepted if the person were female. Or brown. Etc.

I would also want to know if a gay couple could get married in that church that says they accept gay people
Let's be honest, though. In most churches, getting in the door is what get things started. No church is going to go from no gays to gay marriage overnight (or at least it is not likely). I am willing to bet that a lot of the congregations who supported ordination of gay ministers in 1988 would have balked at same sex marriage at that time but were perfectly fine with it (or even actively supported it) in 2003-2005 when the court decisions started coming in. And the proportion of Canadians in favour of same sex marriage went from about 50-50 at the time Martin brought in the new marriage act to a large majority in favour by the 10th anniversary. I know we all want revolutions, but human cultures are generally more evolutionary than revolutionary, with the revolutions only coming when there is resistance to that evolution leading to conflict.
 
I agree Mendalla. Still, it's 2022. There should be even a sliver of acceptance if they are truly welcoming of gay people.
 
I agree Mendalla. Still, it's 2022. There should be even a sliver of acceptance if they are truly welcoming of gay people.
Mystic never said when these happened, but given that I have heard him tell the organist story before, I am pretty sure it was a long time before 2022. Who knows where that church is at now?
 
Mystic never said when these happened, but given that I have heard him tell the organist story before, I am pretty sure it was a long time before 2022. Who knows where that church is at now?

That's a good point. Still, if you claim to accept gay people accept them fully.
 
When you accept Jesus as your Lord and Saviour -----there is only one label ------Born Again ----there is no Jew or Greek ---no slave or free ----no gay or lesbian ---no male or female ==no "progressive" or "conservative" Labels ------

Your all one in Christ Jesus -----all old labels are erased ------

2 Corinthians 5:17​

17 Therefore, if anyone is in Christ, he is a new creation. The old has passed away; behold, the new has come.
 
When you accept Jesus as your Lord and Saviour -----there is only one label ------Born Again ----there is no Jew or Greek ---no slave or free ----no gay or lesbian ---no male or female ==no "progressive" or "conservative" Labels ------

Your all one in Christ Jesus -----all old labels are erased ------

2 Corinthians 5:17​

17 Therefore, if anyone is in Christ, he is a new creation. The old has passed away; behold, the new has come.

And anyone who doesn't accept Jesus in the prescribed manner is hooped. :rolleyes:
 
The loop is to keep the light out and create dead folk to amuse such gods in a real world of tragic comedy ... a drahm*ah just another shot ... thus those spots in the night; dark Ness ... A Few More Dollars? Primal extraction ... the vast exodus ... may resemble dervishes ... cognizant dissonances? The rush to go ...
 
Back
Top