UCCan Talk Reviewing Programs

Welcome to Wondercafe2!

A community where we discuss, share, and have some fun together. Join today and become a part of it!

Threads about the United Church of Canada

JayneWonders

Administrator
Pronouns
She/Her/Her
Hi folks

We have been discussing looking at the overall financials for our congregation. The church has been running a deficit for years, chewing into a large, and now, not so large reserve.

One of the ideas was to look at the costs associated to each program.
The question that I have, as I ponder it, is what would you consider the programs or categories.
Would the programs be your church committee structure, such as worship, Children & Youth, Adult Growth/Spiritual Development, and so on?
Are there other categories you would consider?

How would you allocate staff time?
your custodian likely spends so much time in cleaning or setup for programs, but also does general upkeep on building.
a minister's salary may be the highest part of the staff budgets, how would you ask the minister to present his salary as an allocation to program?

Note: I have done this type of work in corporate world, and it is not easy, and people sometimes get mired in %, rather than trying to get gross #.s

Curious if anyone has tried it.


The next part that people in the group wanted to do was provide a ranking of importance of the program to the church and the qualitative and quantitative values -- ie how well is the program doing.
 
I wish you well. It will be a tough but important challenge. Part of the minister's time should be personal maintenance and development such as prayer, reading, study. Ask the minister to estimate percent of time spent on this, on worship preparation and leadership, community engagement, pastoral care, administration, and on specific programs. Divide up the minister's personal time among the other tasks. For example, if the personal time is 15%, the other uses of time will be 85%. If a particular program uses 6% of the minister's time that program would also be assigned 6/85*15=1% for a total of 7% of the minister's time multiply that number times the total cost of the minister's remuneration including benefits paid by the church.

Use a similar approach for other staff. That helps you determine approximate staff costs for programs.

Then try to divide the building costs among the uses of the building.

Finally calculate the direct costs for each program.

Now take each program, clarify the goals for that program including for whom the program is. Try to assess the results of that program past and present.

Determine how the program is trending and what has affected that trend. Project that trend for about five years.

Now compare costs and results for all your programs. Make this information available to everyone in the congregation. Most members will need weeks to process this information.

Hopefully members will offer their comments and there will be conversations about how to improve some programs, how to let go of some programs, how to shift responsibility for some programs, and possibly about the vision or goals of the congregation.

The numbers do not have to be precise.

Shalom.
 
Always remember this is about business industry and nothing about people ... they are just numbers regardless of their quality!

The cheaper the better as you get to bottom line there is nothing but emotional content!
 
A painful challenge for businesses and organizations is letting go of programs and products that have passed their best before date

In 2000, a presentation by Peter Drucker for a conference of churches in Southern Alberta provided a tough challenge. He said businesses need to track the growth of their products or services. When the growth slows down, have or get another product or service in the market.

For churches, this includes not letting successful programs prevent developing new programs. A major cause of decline by churches is being distracted by a particularly successful program from their vision or mission. Success can breed failure. Failure can breed success.
 
It was on a VHS tape that was borrowed from the UCC resources or from Alberta and North West Conference. I do not remember how I got it. The same package had a story by a presenter from a conference of the Methodist Churches in the States. After he made his presentation, a woman came up to him, introduced herself as chair of a church council, and asked him who Luke was. The presenter used that true story of how a major problem for churches is that many of their leaders have little grounding in the Christian faith including the Bible.
 
It isn't a simple task to get this kind of information.

I've had to and also required others to record their daily activities, assigning to categories, in 15min slots.
It is not a simple task to do; however, it can be eye opening for both the individual recording and the organization as a whole.
Generally, notes are included so one can go back & say what type of admin, or break it out further into say a team member that requires a lot of support.

I have not had much interest in people doing this item in a church environment.

If it isn't tracked, but, is just guestimated, then, the evaluation may be on one's gut feeling, versus what actually is occurring.
 
I think that monetizing programs is a difficult thing to measure.

One example in our church is our (previously annual) Peace Labyrinth. Doesn't cost a great deal of money, but it does eat up volunteer resources rather alarmingly at a busy time of year. Requires a team to both set up and take down (and there's usually at least one meal involved), and a real team to act as docents for the labyrinth while it's open. I've always said that if it helps to heal one person over the season that it's worth it, but I may be overestimating the worth of helping only one person...
 
That's a great point.

I had wanted at one point to track volunteer hours against programs.
I feel it was important and agree that we spend way too much time evaluating dollars and ignoring the burnout of volunteers.
 
And some things are just cheaper than others.

My FFCE team runs on pennies. We purchase Junior Church curriculum (the Whole People of God), and I spend a little bit on adult programming (big $20 for a five week Lenten series that can be re-used), the weekly bible study costs nothing but the resources of our ridiculous number of retired ministers. And it's a useful team. Lots of solid friendships and good learning happens. And the FFCE Team Leader can be the same for years (that's me), because it doesn't demand enough to cause burnout.

However, the Outreach Team is another matter altogether. This is a hugely busy group, with an on-going slate of programs (all carefully and regularly vetted for effectiveness and cost) that burns out the team leader every five years or so. And it costs a lot of money. Right now, on their plate are food programs (from the Little Pantry to our rotating support for various food banks in the City), a weekly breakfast for the homeless population downtown, heavy participation in a homeless advocacy group, a regular benevolent fund, Mother's Day gift boxes for two different women's shelters, they look after refugee sponsorship when we are doing so (our several Syrian family initiatives have wound down, but I anticipate a need to support Ukrainian refugees), they run election debates with a focus on holy manners and social justice questions, they liaise with M&S and Amnesty and Kairos...
 
This is the most important part. The scariest commodity (and I hate to use the word commodity) in most churches is volunteer talent, energy, and time.
 
volunteer talent, energy, and time.

Yep, and even in healthier churches, COVID and the advancing age of our members, make this a weak point.

OTOH, there's something particularly tough, and "Energizer Bunny" like about many lifelong 80 and 90 year old members, particularly the rural ones.
 
Yep, and even in healthier churches, COVID and the advancing age of our members, make this a weak point.

OTOH, there's something particularly tough, and "Energizer Bunny" like about many lifelong 80 and 90 year old members, particularly the rural ones.

This can work for or against what might be good in the longer run!
 
It's a big task! Jim has laid out what seems a helpful (albeint labour intensive)process when it comes to $$.

When it comes to evaluating activities - I think it's really important to step back to the foundational "why" (as per Simon Sinek) of why the church continues to exist. What impact is it really seeking to make in the neighbourhood, in the world? When the why & desired impact is well known & agreed upon, programmes and their budgets can be viewed in that context, not simply in competition with one another. Do the programmes actually 'move the needle' in the direction of desired impact? How do they do that? What investment ($$, time, talent) is required to make those things happen?

I think it's interesting when 'propgrammes/activities' are sometimes explored - that the 'worship' budget may escape close scrutiny. Is worship becoming a 'small group' programme in some churches, while eating up huge untouchable resources? What changes might be made to free up resources for other missional activities? As has been seen during COVID - lots of online & sharing options exist - and yet, there is still a historic pattern of engaging people to create a 'brand new' service EVERY week. I wonder if this will change. I know this is bound to be an unpopular thought in some circles.

John Pentland, in his book "Fishing Tips - How Curiosity Transformed a Community of Faith" - when he gets to the issue of budget about mid-way through - states pretty clearly - Pay for what you WANT, not for what you HAVE. This is not a Pollyanna perspective - but a shift in philosophy - from a scarcity mindset to one of abundance. I do recommend the book if you've not yet read it. It's a good study for a church council.
 
Now comes the hard stuff:. Getting agreement on the difference people want to make as a congregation and the specifics of how to make that difference. It will is also the time of blessing when some people see an opportunity they needed to make a difference and increase their engagement in the congregation, when making a difference increases the significance of coming to church.
 
Interesting discussion. When it comes to worship, yes it does eat up resources. But if we shift to community engagement as our mission, have we lost our reason for existing?

Many social service agencies would describe their reason for existing exactly the same way.

Just wondering.
 
In a healthy church, I'd see the big team spenders as Outreach, Property and Worship.

The smaller spenders as Faith Formation & Christian Ed, Pastoral and Congregational Life.

The team juggling all of this: Stewardship & Finance.
 
Remember that you cannot please everyone all the time as there will always be some that will debate grace and giving in lieu of receiving mores ...

Thus ongoing conflict in reality about abstracts as creative and unsettling to the absolutes ... does that fix some perspectives?

May explain those stares in church ... that odd vacant look! Is criminology preferred to give work to high paid professionals as well robed ... thus head holes sometimes known as Sarah Chasm ... when you note something is Dunne gone ... dear departed thoughts! Emotionally this happens as irrationality ... some refer to it as the reason to stele away ...
 
Back
Top