Mr Paradox just put 17 ties in the donation pile. He kept 4 nice ones.
Good for him. Not his fault that every child's default "gift for Dad" is often the option when they run out of time/imagination.
My youngest sister is awesome at giving me stuff I need/want/can consume. I have homemade socks and hats and half mitts for walking in the fall/spring, cowls, shawls, etc., all beautiful, perfect, and usually timeless. (She also, without charge, repairs socks that she's made, with perfect patches, or more likely, a "re-knitted area". For her, I make stuff that I do well (food and cosmetics): special butter, special salve, gluten-light pie shells for the freezer (1/2 spelt flour), special brownies and truffles. Also, I like to give her give her experience gifts - goat and alpaca visits, etc. I paid for our full half day at the museum of the last silk mill in England. Her goal is to live in a de-commissioned city bus turned into an RV for her and the cats and the motorcycle, so I'm seriously not giving her "stuff", unless it's something that will come in handy for the bus, like a single induction burner that I had in the storage.
My other sister, not so much...one of her last gifts was the most hilariously gaudy and ugly cake plate/stand (we have sorta given up on the gift thing, and largely, on the relationship thing). She knew I cooked/baked for the church. Did she know I have made very few successful cakes in my life, that I specialize in Indian food, pastries and English puddings like trifle... So one more thing (it's currently living underneath the china cabinet) to dispose of.