UCCan Talk Reporting Structures in churches

Welcome to Wondercafe2!

A community where we discuss, share, and have some fun together. Join today and become a part of it!

Threads about the United Church of Canada

JayneWonders

Administrator
Pronouns
She/Her/Her
Who do all your staff report to in your church?

In the M&P guidelines, it indicates that committees can have supervisory roles, such as when the Property committee supervises the custodian.

I'm curious how your churches are setup, and if you feel that the setup is due to your size?
Also, how does it work in practice? Do you feel that there is good supervision and/or support for employees (ministerial and/or lay)
 
Oh, the eternal nightmare of who supervises the custodian.

At the moment, the chair of the property team supervises the custodian, with help/input from M&P. It hasn't gone terribly well in the last few years; the reduced hours of the custodian have really interfered with his life and his commitment; CERB helped a bit, but not total compensation. And we have a really nice team of mixed gender who make up the property team, but no-one wants to lead it. And it won't be me...

With many exceptions, custodial staff don't come from the very bright. Often, they will be brilliant with consistent kind guidance. It's a lot to expect of volunteers.

We seem to do better with the secretary/admin assist role. They have to fit with the minister and the board chair to some extent, and the treasurer. We haven't had many "mis-fits" as much as changing circumstances, and this isn't a role we struggle with. Ditto, music director/pianist, which has been one and two roles.
 
Sometimes there is no collaboration or cooperation as there are those that just go and do things without any communication ... there have been sign pop up as warnings of how dis collaborated things can go ...

Yet who really cares ... for if you interfere with the powers ... well you know and thus collaborators retreat into the megi forest!

Follow this in For Whom the Belle Tolls ... from which we get guerilla warfare ... reactions from the shadowlands ... few could see it coming because ... well! They didn't give a hoot ... the sign in the night of far off wisdom (stay clear of what's in humanity)! It is like a dark pearl of recognition of concern, trouble, etc. Everything that knowing nothing can bring down ... nemesis? Somewhat paradoxical like powers saying the people need to be led and the powers don't ... because power is perfect ... imagine that corrupt statement!

Sometimes there is communication, cooperation and networking ... a alien concept among the autonomous ...
 
Thanks Bette, yes, the challenge of volunteers who may not have supervisory experience, let alone leadership experience.

Question, who do the other staff in your congregation report to?
 
the challenge of volunteers who may not have supervisory experience, let alone leadership experience.
This was kind of the point of a post that I started and then never completed. Unless your church is blessed with people with a management background (I know my employer's former VP was an elder in a Presbyterian church who benefited heavily from his leadership skills and experience), you've sometimes got people with little or no knowledge of things like organizational leadership, employment standards, or best practices for HR being thrust into a supervisory role and little or no support for them. It's a bit of a risk, especially in a world where employees are getting more assertive and litigious around standards and rights. At work, I kind of got the supervisory role shoved on me but I had been with the company something like six years and had HR and my own supervisor to mentor me and back me up.
 
The whole issue of 'reporting to' and 'supervision' is a complex one I think. A strong M&P committee is crucial - and recruitment of people with appropriate skills is important IMO, rather than simply accepting volunteers to this role. Ensuring good training for M&P is important - region usually provides for these opportunities in the UCCan. The 2019 rewrite on the M&P handbook is VERY useful I think - having struggled years ago to work on & chair M&P at a former church, with a bare bones handbook/manual available. M&P, staff, & congregation should be made aware of its availability.

We had a established M&P liaison person for each staff member & committee members had regular informal (lunch or coffee) check-in meetings, along with annual performance reviews which included updating of contracts & revision of any job descriptions. Delivering accolades is as important (or maybe moreso) than discussion about room for improvement. In their day-to-day work tho, the primary engagement was of course with the various committees which they connected.

Some language of accountability & supervision can pose big challenges - coming to shared understanding of how these are lived in one's setting can be helpful. Micro-managing is grave danger I think and damages respectful relationship. Clear job descriptions, that also include 'who to go to for what & when' can be very helpful.

The decision-making hierarchy of a church culture may be challenging. In my former church, there were strong collegial relationships, team ministry, participatory decision making & flattened hierarchy. In others I have known the structure is very different - minister is 'top dog' and nobody does anything at all without minister approval; decisions often deferred to one individual with no sense of ownership by the wider group. That said, these are larger urban congregations & things may be different in much smaller churches.

To Bette's point re custodian - my church moved to contracting out of custodial services many long years ago. That can also be an opportunity to support a social enterprise.
 
Your model sounds good Carolla. I feel it is important to ensure good ongoing relationships, and simulating the manager / HR type relationships in other organizations.

Poorly worded contracts or job descriptions are a nightmare.
 
Overhauling all the position descriptions was a very important task our M&P cttee took on. Lots of consultation occured with staff about what they ACTUALLY do & how long it takes, why it is important, understanding their priorities & challenges within the system of the church operation, seeing what might be streamlined (OMG change! new software! efficient systems!;)) getting them all properly documented & then shared out to congregation was important. SO many assumptions can occur!
 
Agreed, and how do you hold anyone accountable if their job description is inaccurate.
Note: The concept of accountability is a protection for an employee. Nothing like having 20 masters, and a job description which has nothing about what your supervisor wants you to do.
I feel the church is lacking overall in setting goals for the year, and actually discussing if a goal is shifting, or how the goal was met. (Goals need to be SMART).
Without appropriate goal setting, or measuring, then, there is little hope of agreement re how someone is doing.
 
Has anyone ever considered whether you could outsource or contract the HR function for a church, and what the costs would be?

M&P issues can be so divisive and time consuming especially if things are out of hand.
 
Last edited:
Has anyone ever considered whether you could outsource or contract the HR function for a church, and what the costs would be?

M&P issues can be so divisive and time consuming especially if things are out of hand.
I used to know a local HR consultant who was a member of a church that I occasionally attended (we met her there, that's how I knew). Not sure if the church actually used or hired her as a resource or not, though. She did some work for my employer during a period when we were between HR directors and helped me with my first hire so I know she's good.
 
What matters is that the structure meets the current needs and capacities of the congregation, includes an open and helpful route for transferring power and responsibility, and facilitates future evolution as needed to meet the changing circumstances of the congregation.
 
Back
Top