Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Yes, I agree with all of this.Religious adherence guides"?" your moral and ethical compass, your sense of purpose and meaning, it sets up a community so gives you a sense of belonging
Here is where we part company. This may be true of some religious sects and denominations. But not all. Liberal Christians have rituals for sure but I don't see or experience them as controlling.it has rituals and practices to keep you controlled,
More than the appearance of comfort, in my experience.it appears to offer comfort in face of hardship
Maybe.and it influence all your personal and societal goals.
Not sure about this one.So I'd say you don't have your own choices only those controlled by your faith.
That's pretty good, coming from someone who's an atheist and an observer. Of course it's not totally accurate IMO but I appreciate your perspective.Religious adherence guides"?" your moral and ethical compass, your sense of purpose and meaning, it sets up a community so gives you a sense of belonging it has rituals and practices to keep you controlled, it appears to offer comfort in face of hardship, and it influence all your personal and societal goals.
So I'd say you don't have your own choices only those controlled by your faith.
Do you think you would be different without faith to help shape your values? How?Religion and spirituality are a source of values, there is no doubt. And that is not always coercion. After all, my embrace of the UU principles was entirely voluntary and they very much influence choices I make. UUs call themselves the "Chosen Faith" for a reason. Most UUs chose to be UUs rather than being "brought up in the faith". And I think that is true of many Christians, too, even conservative and mainstream ones.
However, the question was not whether religion is indoctrinated but whether faith influences choices and I would say, yes it does. Possibly inevitably. Since faith speaks to our beliefs about our place in reality, it influences and shapes our values, or at least reflects them (in the case of a chosen faith per above), and one would hope that we make choices that are in keeping with our values.
Perhaps "boundaries" gets confused with control?Yes, I agree with all of this.
Here is where we part company. This may be true of some religious sects and denominations. But not all. Liberal Christians have rituals for sure but I don't see or experience them as controlling.
More than the appearance of comfort, in my experience.
Maybe.
Not sure about this one.
Hmm. I have had debates about boundaries vs barriers with a clergyperson who liked to say that Jesus got rid of boundaries.Perhaps "boundaries" gets confused with control?
Quite probably I would be different but the how is very hard. After all, I grew up liberal Christian. A lot of my values and even some of my beliefs are still deeply rooted in that upbringing even post-UU (after all, UUism came out of theological movements in Christianity). So it is hard to disentangle faith from other influences.Do you think you would be different without faith to help shape your values? How?
Quite probably I would be different but the how is very hard. After all, I grew up liberal Christian. A lot of my values and even some of my beliefs are still deeply rooted in that upbringing even post-UU (after all, UUism came out of theological movements in Christianity). So it is hard to disentangle faith from other influences.
Hellenistic Greek philosophy is an influence due to my Classics degree, so perhaps I would be more Epicurean or Stoic than I really am now. But I am not sure what that me really looks like. Epicureanism leans dangerously close to hedonism if one is not careful or misinterprets parts of it but I am not really the right temperament for that. But Stoicism, while closer to Christian values in some regards, is bit too cold and impersonal so not sure I have the right temperament for that either.
It is an interesting mental exercise but, like all alternate universes, speculation at best.