During my tour of Israel we stayed overnight in a little motel on the east bank of the Sea of Galilee just opposite Tiberias on the west bank. The next mornng brought an insight that was a highlight of our tour for me. Right next to our motel was a significant mountain near the sea and I realized that this must be the mountain of the contiguous stories of the Feeding of the 5,000 followed by Jesus walking on the water in John 6:1-21.
After the feeding miracle Jesus sends His disciples by boat towards Capernaum and goes up the mountain of the feeding site, presumably to spend time in prayer (6:21). the next time the disciples see Him, He is walking on water beside the boat in a strong wind. 2 geographical details of the story indicate tbat the mountain adjacent to our motel is the scene of the Feeding of the 5,000.
(1) Spectators from ancient Tiberias across the sea notice that the disciples have left the mountain without Jesus and row boats to try in vain to track Jesus down there (6:22-23). Modern Tiberias is directly across from the mountain and the adjacent motel where we were staying and its lights made the sea shine like a pearl after dark.
(2) On their boat journey to Capernaum, the disciples are 3 1/2 miles out (= "25 ot 30 stadia"--6:19) when they see Jesus walking on the water.
This detail places their point of departure several miles down the east side of the 13-mile long Sea of Galilee. The mountain beside our motel is the only candidate for the mountain visible from Tiberias, ;which is just over half way down the west side of the sea of Galilee. So the disciples are just over half way to Capernaum when they see Jesus walking on the water.
I pointed all this out to our Israeli tour guide, Kenny, and he said the mountain was on private property and, to his knowledge, had never been excavated in search of archaeological signs like buried inscriptions commemorating the Feeding miracle. There is a chance that some ancient inscription or other ancient memento lies buried somewhere on that mountain.
This geographical evidence supplements the case made by Cambridge scholar C. H. Dodd in his magisterial book "History and Tradition in the Fourth Gospe; for the unique accuracy of historical and cultural details of the Fourth Gospel. Is this the same mountain on which Jesus' resurrection appearance in Matthew 28:16-20 occurred in a prearranged site familiar to Jesus' Galilean followers?