I love the Church in The Wildwood - its wording is limited by its time of writing, however, the tune is steadfast and memorable. I bet you won't find many that know the song who are under 30.
Perhaps because of unnatural concerns of modernity?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I love the Church in The Wildwood - its wording is limited by its time of writing, however, the tune is steadfast and memorable. I bet you won't find many that know the song who are under 30.
Hi, Bette,
The writer. John Newton, refers to himself as a wretch because he was in the horrid business of hauling kidnapped Africans into slavery in England and the Colonies. He repented of his sin, but spent much of his life in the slave trade before doing so and becoming an abolitionist. Hence, he was a "wretch", at the very least, because of his miserable trafficking in human beings.
Thank you, nutmeg; yes, I knew the history of the writer as former slave trader. However, I still maintain that a constant focus on one's sins, one's past, is a sure-fired recipe for an unhealthy today.
@revsdd - Thanks! You bring up an interesting conversation. If you have to know the theology and/or history of a hymn song then what is it's value to the regular people in the pew, and/or kids in church who don't know the history or for that matter care.
I would agree with your critique of More Voices.Jobam said:MVU uses a lot of poetic and flowery lyrics which kids can't relate to thus I wonder of their validity in a few years...
Many of the best known ones would promote a theology that most in the United Church (of either Christ or Canada) would be uncomfortable with. And we mustn't be challenged by things that make us uncomfortable.Jobam said:In the US many contemporary music groups/artists have writers who write their songs. Are there no professional current song writers that the UCC can tap into? Our sister church, The United Church of Christ in the states has the same issue.
Knowing the theology of a hymn doesn't require theological training. It is a matter of listening to the hymn, and then discerning what the hymn writer is saying. It means asking what makes me comfortable or uncomfortable with the hymn, and then asking why.
Finding the history of a hymn is simple. There are all sorts of books and websites that will fill one in on the background of a hymn of particular interest. Pastors should also take on some of that role. It's not uncommon for me to introduce a hymn with some reference to the hymn's background.
If people "don't ... care" then that's a problem. Are they in church to be entertained or discipled? If the latter, they care. If the former, let's just close up shop now because there are lots of things more entertaining than going to church.
I would agree with your critique of More Voices.
Many of the best known ones would promote a theology that most in the United Church (of either Christ or Canada) would be uncomfortable with. And we mustn't be challenged by things that make us uncomfortable.
I didn’t know the history of Amazing Grace. Somehow, I always thought that it was the story of a prostitute being saved.
I am not kidding. I guess, I just had that image that “ a wretch like me” must be a prostitute.And her name was "Grace" and she was really good at her work so that the guys all yelled out "Amazing Grace" as they ...?
I am not kidding.
so I live between 2 women who have written songs for More Voices. Linnea Good sometimes reminds folks that she is the youngest composer in Voices United. and Keri Whelander (sp?) is not much older. and sometimes they collaborate on a song.
Newton was speaking of himself of course and reflecting on his wretched past as a slave trader and slave ship captain. Even after his conversion and his ordination and his realization of grace he was tormented by the thought of those he had delivered from Africa to slavery in America and that God would show him grace was truly amazing to him. He became quite active in the abolitionist movement in England.I am not kidding. I guess, I just had that image that “ a wretch like me” must be a prostitute.
In the book, "What's so Amazing About Grace" by Philip Yancey, there is a story about a prostitute in the first chapter I believe. Maybe that's the connection?... if you read it?I am not kidding. I guess, I just had that image that “ a wretch like me” must be a prostitute.
I didn’t know the history of Amazing Grace. Somehow, I always thought that it was the story of a prostitute being saved.
I am not kidding. I guess, I just had that image that “ a wretch like me” must be a prostitute.
And I was. I can't resist mildly smutty wordplay.
Nope, didn’t read it.In the book, "What's so Amazing About Grace" by Philip Yancey, there is a story about a prostitute in the first chapter I believe. Maybe that's the connection?... if you read it?
Again your wide knowledge base is amazingHi, Bette,
The writer. John Newton, refers to himself as a wretch because he was in the horrid business of hauling kidnapped Africans into slavery in England and the Colonies. He repented of his sin, but spent much of his life in the slave trade before doing so and becoming an abolitionist. Hence, he was a "wretch", at the very least, because of his miserable trafficking in human beings.