• A member of the original wondercafe, Punkins has passed away. There's a thread in the In Memoriam section
  • Our new header image is our own private beach. See Council News & Business for more.

Let's talk about the Resurrection

PilgrimsProgress

Well-Known Member
Messages
982
Reaction score
1,372
As a person who is part of the so-called "progressive" theology movement, I'm often surprised how narrow are the interpretations of the resurrection - not only by conservative Christians, but also by agnostics and atheists.

Here is a quote that caught my attention -

"My response to that question on resurrection was read by some as a propositional one, but I never said that I don’t believe in the bodily resurrection. I simply pointed out that in the Gospel of Mark there is no bodily resurrection and that the tradition has a variety of ways of thinking about resurrection. I’ve gotten responses from people who think that I’m no longer Christian because of some of the things I said. My aim was to show there is space within Christianity for myriad interpretations and existential engagements with biblical texts." - Serene Jones- President of Union Theological Seminary.


Do you think this is a fair comment?

What is your personal belief regarding the resurrection?
 

Luce NDs

Well-Known Member
Messages
40,322
Reaction score
3,609
No matter what ... someone will drag it up again as a reminder of the downfall of mankind from encounters with the other kind ... some people just don't like encounters of that sort!

It goes to prove how odd people are even though they believe they are perfect! The POTUS say everybody believes it ... and they couldn't be wrong about his statements ...
 

chansen

Pleasant Enough
Messages
10,054
Reaction score
7,085
I think that, with no verifiable exceptions, dead bodies have an annoying habit of staying dead. Those that refuse to abide by this rule were probably *almost* dead. There is a difference between *almost* dead and *completely* dead, as we learned in The Princess Bride.

If, by some sort of miracle, an exception was granted 2000 years ago, I fail to see why I have to give up my Sunday mornings to celebrate it. Surely, one good shindig should have sufficed.
 

PilgrimsProgress

Well-Known Member
Messages
982
Reaction score
1,372
??? Mark 16:6
Guessing serene ran out of toilet paper one night.
Mark 16:6 just says he was "raised" and isn't still in the burial place......

Doesn't necessarily mean a body resurrection - perhaps spirit/soul?
Could mean the burial place was robbed, and the body taken?
 

PilgrimsProgress

Well-Known Member
Messages
982
Reaction score
1,372
I think that, with no verifiable exceptions, dead bodies have an annoying habit of staying dead.
I tend to agree.......
But I still have a shy hope in an afterlife -as for its form I'll have to wait and see. Maybe there is, maybe there isn't.......
 

Luce NDs

Well-Known Member
Messages
40,322
Reaction score
3,609
There then is the raising of the question where did mental attributes go? This is the sinking sensation that the psyche is in the place of the -1 ... especially for those believing there isn't anything beneath the physical binary system of 0's and 1's again ...

Of course this is all abstract construct that is below those opposed to Rae thinking ... how light converts within the vegetating portions!

I've been told so many times that there is no such thing as a social psyche construct ... and yet whole academies are studying it as it diminishes in the shadow of overwhelming desire to shoot down the neighbour ... some of us make satire and metaphor of it .. so the heir ups won't recognize where the laughter came from ... nowhere;s but partisan territory?

Did you know in a spectrum of understanding that partisan forces once referred to the underground movements? Can you make something of subtle issues? Kinda like autism and autistic stretches that reach out into pedestrian domains ... there's a scene in Ghost that is particularly good about subtle mysteries grabbing the perpetrators ... maybe just a useless phantom of thought ... in essence?

G'way with yah boies! Is a broken heart a concept that gnaws on the abstract? Listen to The Long Dark Veil and its lyrics and tell me what's gome MS'n! If something is extracted from a legend ... is it negative domain? More underground activity ...

I do hope there is something left for my offspring once the "presence" generation gets over their self worries ... that they've got enough to resist the neighbours! What we need is more walls and baffling immaterials ... abstracts! Some say it was all a faint dark reflection ... sort of glassy eye'd/aye 'd response ... Ide ... that's it, that blind pas 'dis tuff! "Pas deuce"?
 
Last edited:
Messages
3,036
Reaction score
1,099
Mark 16:6 just says he was "raised" and isn't still in the burial place......

Doesn't necessarily mean a body resurrection - perhaps spirit/soul?
Could mean the burial place was robbed, and the body taken?
The Word of Promise® NKJV Audio Bible

Mark 16:6

6 But he said to them, “Do not be alarmed. You seek Jesus of Nazareth, who was crucified. He is risen! He is not here. See the place where they laid Him.

Look somewhere else for your loopholed.
 

chansen

Pleasant Enough
Messages
10,054
Reaction score
7,085
The Word of Promise® NKJV Audio Bible

Mark 16:6

6 But he said to them, “Do not be alarmed. You seek Jesus of Nazareth, who was crucified. He is risen! He is not here. See the place where they laid Him.

Look somewhere else for your loopholed.
"Risen" does not necessarily mean he got up and stumbled out of his own tomb. Someone could have come and got the body with a forklift and just moved him to a higher resting place.
 

Luce NDs

Well-Known Member
Messages
40,322
Reaction score
3,609
Thus lighter old parables drift in eddies causing turbulence for the straight up sorts! Nietzsche referred to this as inferred chaos ... may be a stimulace for more!
 

Waterfall

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,302
Reaction score
3,614
Possibly, Serene Jones, may have been referring to a spiritual resurrection, which is another interpretation among other explanations.
Mark 16:9-20 is not found in earlier manuscripts,( it was inserted much later). These additional words are questionable and seem to want to confirm a bodily resurrection, albeit in a different form, in order to expand on the previous verses including Mark 16:6.
 

JRT

Me on the left.
Messages
135
Reaction score
190
In the days and weeks following the crucifixion, the apostles and disciples returned to Galilee in shock and disbelief at what had happened. However, it gradually dawned on them that, if the life and teachings of Jesus were to have any lasting impact, it could only happen by and through them. That is equally true of us today. They and we are the true resurrection. I believe that the resurrection stories in the gospels are attempts to express this idea as an allegory.
 

Mendalla

Eastern Lowland Gorilla
Messages
25,946
Reaction score
14,464
In the days and weeks following the crucifixion, the apostles and disciples returned to Galilee in shock and disbelief at what had happened. However, it gradually dawned on them that, if the life and teachings of Jesus were to have any lasting impact, it could only happen by and through them. That is equally true of us today. They and we are the true resurrection. I believe that the resurrection stories in the gospels are attempts to express this idea as an allegory.
That's basically my take as well. I do not think there was a literal physical resurrection, but the idea is a powerful piece of myth-making about an idea so strong, it overcame death.
 

Waterfall

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,302
Reaction score
3,614
That's basically my take as well. I do not think there was a literal physical resurrection, but the idea is a powerful piece of myth-making about an idea so strong, it overcame death.
But if it was only that, many have had strong ideas over the years that manifested into great movements.....so do you think the church invented something (body resurrection) in order to perpetuate a religion? Do you think Christianity would have spread as widely without it?
 

Mendalla

Eastern Lowland Gorilla
Messages
25,946
Reaction score
14,464